Deluca has played in 21 of the 22 competitions during her career. She ranked second on the team in the 2010-2011 season with an 88.7 average as her 15.5 rounds played were tied for first. As a sophomore, her 86.9 average was second on the team and her 14 rounds were tied for second. Deluca led the team with a three-round score of 247 and a 36th place finish at the 2009 Big South Championship. Her 81 in the first round was a career best. She was also named to the 2009-2010 Big South Conference Presidential Honor Roll. As a freshman, she tied for second on the team with 13 rounds played.
McCarthy earned 2009-2010 Big South Conference Presidential Honor Roll accolades. She has played in four rounds during her career. She made her collegiate debut as a freshman at the Mount Holyoke Invitational.